Abrahamic faiths (Judaism, Christianity and Islam) always placed human life separate from other life on Earth.
When we look at how humans are made, it is obvious we are not separate at all from other lifeforms nor we are separate from the planet we live in.
99% of the mass of the human body is made up of just six elements: Oxygen, Carbon, Hydrogen, Nitrogen, Calcium, and Phosphorus. The rest is composed of elements such as Potassium, Sulfur and Sodium. We can find all the elements we’re made of in our environment, here on Earth.
All those elements are held together by the same atomic forces we see in the rest of the physical world.
Our physiology, chemistry and even behavior is consistent with the other animal lifeforms on Earth. We have the same skeletal, digestive, muscular, cardiovascular, nervous and reproductive system as apes, for example. Most of our DNA is the same as most other animal species on Earth.
If we would have been magically created fully formed, we could expect to function under unique principles. Why would we need organs to convert food into energy? Why would we have vestigial organs? Why would we need neurons to think and memorize things? If we came from the realm of magic, why can’t we see a single trace of magic around us?
To realize that we are part of the natural world on all levels can actually be quite comforting. It confirms that we do belong right here, on Earth.